Pages

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Experimenting with Fluxx

Mod Ideas
  1. What if my game only had rules apply to one player?
  2. What my game was about Organ Transplants?
  3. What if my game was about superheroes?
  4. What if Keeper Cards had effects too?
  5. What fi goals were for individuals instead of shared among all the players?
  6. What if a board was made to accompany the game?
  7. What if more player interactivity was involved?
  8. What if players had to make certain movements?
  9. What if rules had durations?
  10. What if rules worked off of addition instead of replacement?
  11. What if more types of players were involved?
  12. If a board was made, what if the player could move between goals?
  13. If goals applied to a single person, then what if they rotated among the players?
  14. If Keeper cards had effects, what if they had either positive or negative effects while the action cards had the opposite?
  15. If the game was Organ Donor related, what if players were more like Doctors, the Goal cards as patients, and the Keepers were organs?
  16. What if action cards were more like temporary Rule cards?
  17. What if action cards were the movement cards in a board game?
  18. If a board was made, what if the movement of the player is determined by dice rolls?
  19. What if the space was changed? Bigger? Smaller? Taller?
  20. What if instead of cards, they were more like Jenga pieces and they had types or effects like that of the cards?
  21. What if there was more skill involved, such as allowing more cards that allow a player to choose cards from either the deck or discard pile?

When playing without mods, the game had a sense of quickness and changed on the fly. This is normal game behavior and is attributed to the fact that rules change all the time during the game. When there are times the rules were not changing that often, it felt slow. Once more, this is all to be expected. One problem that was clearly evident was that with the changing rules, it was hard to keep track of how many cards to draw and how many to play.

The first mod I tried was making Goal cards apply only to the person who played them. This had an interesting effect that I had not foreseen. A certain Creeper, the Radioactive Potato, would switch players when the goal changed. If the goal did not change, then a player was stuck with the Creeper. In this modded version of the game, a player who refused to change their own goal was stuck with the potato. They had to rely on another player to play a card that discarded this Creeper. This was a little easier to include more strategy into the game since goals were not as short lived. More long term strategies could be formulated as opposed to the unmodded version.

Another mod I tried to play with was the way to keep track of how many cards to draw and play. Temporarily, we incorporated pennies in the game as game tokens. We used them as counters for each person to draw and play cards. They were a success for keeping track of the numbers instead of mathematically creating the sums in on the spot. There were some parts where it was hard to keep track for everyone because of certain cards and rules (such as the Poor Bonus, No Hand Bonus, Rich Bonus, etc.). To remedy this that player was given more pennies to keep by them to help them add quickly for their own personal amount of cards they must draw and play.


The last mod that was given chance before determining major changes will have to occur before further playtesting was applying rule cards to certain people. It was very difficult to keep track of everything and can let a player become overpowered too quickly. One Goal that came up was to have a certain amount of cards to win (this goal was shared amongst the players). A certain player only had to use a Rule card on themself that allowed them to pick up many cards and/or play as little cards as they wished. This also made the game very unbalanced as some players were not given the chance to utilize the cards they needed and others could easily play many cards a round furthering their advancement to their goal. Overall, this was not a very successful mod for the game.

With this knowledge, it has can to my attention that the individual goals was more or less a success and the counter was a large success. The rules should continue to be applied to everyone to keep the game as balanced as possible. I want to start messing with the action cards to create effects that create more strategy. One way I would figure this would work is being able to go through the discard pile or draw pile to pick certain types of cards (such as Keepers, Creepers, Goals, and Rule cards). I may even extract the ability to change the rules and implement it into a new setting to create a new game with Fluxx qualities. I am not sure if this will include a board game or if it may another game set with a different type of winning state. I will have to implement this into different scenarios to get the best effects. I know most definitely that the end product will have a different theme and I am tempted between a doctor/organ transplant theme or a superhero/supervillain theme. This will also need testing to see which is more appealing to my intended audience.

No comments:

Post a Comment